When South Africa’s President Cyril Ramaphosa and his delegation went to Washington in May, they were hoping for a boost and a reset after months of acrimony with Donald Trump’s White House administration. Instead, he was “ambushed,” in the words of several commentators.
In Oval Office scenes reminiscent of the public humiliation endured by Ukraine’s President Zelenskyy earlier this year, Ramaphosa was asked to watch a video showing so-called white “genocide” in South Africa. He kept his cool and did so. It later transpired that one of the images Trump held up in the meeting was in fact a screenshot of a Reuters video taken in the Democratic Republic of Congo.
Supporters of the Trump administration—not least Pretoria-born billionaire Elon Musk—have long amplified claims of violence against South Africa’s white minority, as has former Fox News host Tucker Carlson, who ran segments on this supposed genocide during the president’s first term, but Ramaphosa, 72, was praised for remaining composed and reconciliatory in the face of an angry Trump. Others criticised him for not responding more forcefully to Trump’s accusations.
Zelenskyy was less composed when he fell into Trump’s Oval Office elephant trap in February, the two leaders becoming involved in an unseemly public row. In contrast, Ramaphosa’s measured and good-natured response has shown other world leaders how to navigate and manage Trump’s confected assaults, possibly to the extent that the US president abandons the tactic in the future.
Problems at home
While right-wing Afrikaner groups delighted in Trump’s stunt, Ramaphosa has been good humoured about it, saying only that he was “bemused” and downplaying accusations of an “ambush”.
It may even have served as a distraction, because back in South Africa, he and his ruling African National Congress (ANC) face pressures from every direction. The economy is stagnating, crime is sky high, as is corruption and unemployment, while public services are largely dysfunctional and the country’s infrastructure is crumbling.
There also seems to be very little accountability for those who break the law in South Africa these days. The ANC, itself fractious, has been in an uneasy, messy coalition, in a ‘government of national unity’ (GNU) with ten other parties for almost a year, forced into sharing power after dismal results in national elections.
Trade or ‘genocide’?
In Washington, Ramaphosa sought a trade deal with the US, something to bring business and stability back to South Africa to stimulate economic growth and put people back in work. He said as much in the Oval Office: that US investment could help tackle joblessness, the main reason for high crime rates.